Planck Speed: the Missing Speed of Physics? Absolute Still Without Breaking Lorentz Symmetry!


  •   Espen Gaarder Haug


Today, the speed of light is one of the cornerstones of modern physics. It is the maximum speed limit for transferring information, and plays a very central role in relativity theory. It also seems to be the same as the assumed and measured speed of gravity (gravitons and/or gravitational waves). We are not questioning the speed of light, as we indeed think it is the maximum speed limit and that it is identical to the speed of
gravity, but we also think photons lead us to a second speed limit, which we will term the Planck speed. Photon-photon collisions are part of modern physics, but what is not discussed is the speed of two photons during the very moment of a photon-photon collision. How can photons move during a collision? Or, assume
a photon is reflected by a mirror; to do so it must collide with the building blocks of the mirror, yet how can it be moving during the very collision point? Also, modern physics assumes mass can be created in a photon-photon collision. We suggest this mass is the Planck mass particle and that it only lasts one Planck time, so when two photons collide, we will claim they must stand still for the direct observer. That is, we suggest that
the speed of the Planck mass particle is always zero, but that this zero-velocity can only last for one Planck time. That it only lasts one Planck time means it will not break with the relativity principle or Lorenz symmetry, or at least what we can call weak Lorentz symmetry. We will show that the missing Plank mass particle is the very collision point between two photons, and that this is fully in line with predictions in other researchers’ findings in relation to the possible photon mass. This new view seems to solve the missing mass-gap, and seems able to unify gravity with quantum mechanics. This again seems to unify photons with mass, because one of the long-outstanding questions in physics is whether photons have mass or not. In addition, we show
how to find, in a very simple way directly from gravitational observations, lp/tp= cg = c, which is the upper speed limit (the speed of light and gravity) independent of any knowledge of G or ~ or c.

Keywords: Planck scale, Planck mass particle, photonphoton collision, Compton wavelength, Planck length, Planck speed, speed of gravity


M. Planck. Natuerliche Masseinheiten. Der Koniglich Preussischen ¨ Akademie Der Wissenschaften, 1899.

A. S. Eddington. Report On The Relativity Theory Of Gravitation. The Physical Society Of London, Fleetway Press, London, 1918.

T. Padmanabhan. Planck length as the lower bound to all physical length scales. General Relativity and Gravitation, 17, 1985. URL

R. J. Adler. Six easy roads to the Planck scale. American Journal of Physics, 78(9):925, 2010. URL

S. Hossenfelder. Can we measure structures to a precision better than the Planck length? Classical and Quantum Gravity, 29, 2012. URL

S. Hossenfelder. Minimal length scale scenarios for quantum gravity. Living Reviews in Relativity, 16, 2013. URL

A. Unzicker. The Mathematical Reality: Why Space and Time Are an Illusion. Independently published, 2020.

E. G. Haug. Can the Planck length be found independent of big G ? Applied Physics Research, 9(6):58, 2017. URL

E. G. Haug. Finding the Planck length multiplied by the speed of light without any knowledge of G, c, or h, using a Newton force spring. Journal Physics Communication, 4:075001, 2020a. URL

E. G. Haug. Demonstration that Newtonian gravity moves at the speed of light and not instantaneously (infinite speed) as thought! Journal of Physics Communication., 5(2):1, 2021a. URL

E. G. Haug. Using a grandfather pendulum clock to measure the world’s shortest time interval, the Planck time (with zero knowledge of G). Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics, 9:1076, 2021b.

E. G. Haug. Measurements of the Planck length from a ball-clock without knowledge of Newton’s gravitational constant G or the Planck constant. European Journal of Applied Physics, 3:15, 2021c.

E. G. Haug. Collision space-time: Unified quantum gravity. Physics Essays, 33(1):46, 2020b. URL

E. G. Haug. Rethinking the foundation of physics and its relation to quantum gravity and quantum probabilities: Unification of gravity and quantum mechanics., 2020c. URL

E. G. Haug. Quantum Gravity Hidden In Newton Gravity And How To Unify It With Quantum Mechanics. in the book: The Origin of Gravity from the First Principles, Editor Volodymyr Krasnoholovets, NOVA Publishing, New York, 2021d.

J. R. Buczyna, C. S. Unnikrishnan, and G. T. Gillies. Standard and derived Planck quantities: Selected analysis and observations. Soviet Astronomy Letters, 17(4), 1978.

E. R. Caianiello. Is there a maximal acceleration? Letter Nuovo Cimento, 32:65, 1981. URL

G. Scarpetta. Letter Nuovo Cimento, 51, 1984.

E. R Caianiello, S. D. Filippo, G. Marco, and Vilasi. G. Remarks on the maxlmal-acceleration hypothesis. Letter Nuovo Cimento, 34:112, 1982.

E. R. Caianiello and Landi G. Maximal acceleration and Sakharov’s limiting temperature.

D. F. Falla and P. T. Landsberg. Black holes and limits on some physical quantities. European Journal of Physics, 15, 1994.

J. R. Buczyna, C. S. Unnikrishnan, and G. T. Gillies. Standard and derived Planck quantities: selected analysis and derivations. Gravitation and Cosmology, 17(4):339, 2011. URL EJ-PHYSICS, EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSICS, VOL. 4, NO. 1, JANUARY 2022 17

H. Poincare. The measure of time. ´ English translation by George Bruce Halsted 1913 in the Foundation of Science, 1898.

Georges Sagnac. The demonstration of the luminiferous aether by an interferometer in uniform rotation. Comptes Rendus, 157:708–710, 1913.

G. Spavieri and E. G. Haug. Why the Sagnac effect favors absolute over relative simultaneity. Physics Essays, 32(2):331, 2019. URL

G. Spavieri, G. Gillies, G. Haug, and A. Sanchez. Light propagation and local speed in the linear Sagnac effect. Journal of Modern Optics, 26 (21):2131, 2019. URL

E. T Kipreos and R. S Balachandran. Assessment of the relativistic rotational transformations. Modern Physics Letters A, 36:2150113, 2021. URL

B. P. Abbott et. al. Gravitational waves and gamma-rays from a binary neutron star merger: Gw170817 and GRB 170817a. The Astrophysical Journal Letters, Volume 848, 848(2):1?27, 2017. URL

W. W. Salisbury. Velocity of gravitational waves. Nature, 224, 1969. URL

S. Du, F. Peng, and M. Li. Measuring the speed of gravitational waves with the distorted pulsars. arXiv:1712.05965, 2017.

N. Cornish, D. Blas, and G. Nardini. Bounding the speed of gravity with gravitational wave observations. Physics Review Letter, 119, 2017. URL

E. G. Haug. Extraction of the speed of gravity (light) from gravity observations only. International Journal of Astronomy and Astrophysics, 9(2), 2019. URL

O. J. Pike, F. Mackenroth, E. G. Hill, and Rose S. J. A photon–photon collider in a vacuum Hohlraum. Nature Photonics, 8, 2014. URL

E. G. Haug. Newton and Einstein’s gravity in a new perspective for Planck masses and smaller sized objects. International Journal of Astronomy and Astrophysics, 8, 2018. URL

A. H. Compton. A quantum theory of the scattering of xrays by light elements. Physical Review, 21(5):483, 1923. URL

H. A. Lorentz. Simplified theory of electrical and optical phenomena in moving systems. Proc. Acad. Scientific, Amsterdam, 1, 1899.

A. Einstein. On the electrodynamics of moving bodies. Annalen der Physik, English translation by George Barker Jeffery 1923, (17), 1905. URL

D. C Giancoli. Physics for Scientists & Engineers. Pearson Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 2009.

P. A. Tipler and R. A. Llewellyn. Modern Physics, Third Edition. W. H. Freeman and Company, New York, 1999.

H. Minikowski’s wski. Space and time. A Translation of an Address delivered at the 80th Assembly of German Natural Scientists and Physicians, at Cologne, 21 September, in the book ”The Principle of Relativity”, Dover 1923, 1908.

E. Hecht. Einstein never approved the relativistic mass formula. The Physics Teacher, 47:336, 2009. URL

E. G. Haug. Three dimensional space-time gravitational metric, 3 space + 3 time dimensions. Journal of High Energy Physics, Gravitation and Cosmology, 7:1230, 2021e. URL

E. G. Haug. A new full relativistic escape velocity and a new Hubble related equation for the universe. Physics Essays, 34(4):502, 2021f. URL

M. Planck. Das prinzip der relativitat und die grundgleichungen der ¨ mechanik. Verhandlungen Deutsche Physikalische Gesellschaft, 4, 1906.

C. G. Adler. Dose mass really depends on velocity dad? American Journal of Physics, 55:739, 1987. URL

E. G. Haug. Relativistic Newtonian gravity makes dark energy superfluous?, 2020d.

E. G. Haug. Wormholes do not exist, they are mathematical artifacts from an incomplete gravitational theory (?). HAL archive, 2021g. URL

E. G. Haug. The gravitational constant and the Planck units. A simplification of the quantum realm. Physics Essays, 29(4):558, 2016. URL

E. G. Haug. The ultimate limits of the relativistic rocket equation. The Planck photon rocket. Acta Astronautica, 136, 2017b. URL

E. G. Haug. Unified Revolution, New Fundamental Physics. Oslo, E.G.H. Publishing, 2014.

E. G. Haug. Does special relativity lead to a Trans-Planckian crisis? Applied Physics Research, 12(1), 2020e. URL

E. Schrodinger. ¨ Uber die kr ¨ aftefreie bewegung in der relativistischen ¨ quantenmechanik. Sitzungsberichte der Preußischen Akademie der Wissenschaften. Physikalisch-mathematische Klasse, 1930.

L.S. Levitt. The proton Compton wavelength as the ‘quantum’ of length. Experientia, 14:233, 1958. URL

O. L. Trinhammer and H. G. Bohr. On proton charge radius definition. EPL, 128:21001, 2019. URL 5075/128/21001.

G.T. Gillies, Luo J., and L. C. Tu. The mass of the photon. Reports on Progress in Physics, 6, 2005.

G. Spavieri, J. Quintero, G.T. Gilles, and Rodriguez M. A survey of existing and proposed classical and quantum approaches to the photon mass. The European Physical Journal D, 61:1, 2011. URL

J. Christian. Passage of time in a Planck scale rooted local inertial structure. arXiv:gr-qc/0308028 v3, 2003. URL arXiv:gr-qc/0308028 v3.

J. P. Bruneton. Notes on several phenomenological laws of quantum gravity. arXiv, 2013. URL

D. Meschini. Planck-scale physics: Facts and beliefs. Foundations of Science, 12:277, 2007. URL

D. Mermin. Space and Time in Special Relativity. Waveland Pr Inc, 1989.

Bernard Schutz. Gravity from the Ground Up. Cambridge University Press, 2003.

A. T. Augousti and A. Radosz. An observation on the congruence of the escape velocity in classical mechanics and general relativity in a Schwarzschild metric. European Journal of Physics, 376:331–335, 2006. URL


How to Cite
Haug, E. G. (2022). Planck Speed: the Missing Speed of Physics? Absolute Still Without Breaking Lorentz Symmetry!. European Journal of Applied Physics, 4(1), 11-18.